Who is the creepiest artist of all time? We’ll break down the nominees, watch a wild Cop Cam, and go on a Scum Parade!

The score is currently Vinnie 3 – Karl 3 – Guest 4 visit patreon.com/thecreepoff to vote and decide this week’s winner

Check out this week’s scum parade stories here: 

Cape Cod Car Thief Finds Kilo of Cocaine in Trunk and Alerts Police, Leading to Arrest

18-year-old accused of killing man, living in his home afterwards: Phoenix PD | FOX 10 Phoenix

Riverview mayor charged with sex crimes involving four alleged victims | ksdk.com  

Pittsburgh-area man offered to buy 6-year-old girl for $5,000, police say – CBS Pittsburgh

Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to snag exclusive merch and get an extra bonus episode every week!

Support free speech help to donate to Karl & Shulis Legal fund visit FIGHTHEDABBLER.COM

Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

You can follow our Results girl Danni on Instagram @Danni_Desolation

 Nap time is getting creepy this week. Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for the creepiest daycare worker of all time. On Karl’s Cop Cam, we meet two separate women — one with a good plan, and one with the exact opposite. Plus, a brand-new Scum Parade.

The score is currently Vinnie 2 – Karl 3 – Guest 4 visit patreon.com/thecreepoff to vote and decide this week’s winner

Check out this week’s scum parade stories here: 

Dad on Rampage Tossed Hot Soup on 3-Month-Old & Rubbed Chili Oil in Woman’s Eyes – Crime Online

Rayong man forces wife into sex with his father and pimps her out | Thaiger

‘West Wing’ Star Timothy Busfield Facing Child Sex Abuse Charges, Warrant Issued

Former Child Actor Matt Prokop Arrested on Charges of Child Pornography, Aggravated Assault and Violation of Bond

Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to snag exclusive merch and get an extra bonus episode every week!

If you have a suggestion for the wheel of Consequences, send them to Mahalia at this simple address: creepoffconsequenceideas@gmail.com

Support free speech help to donate to Karl & Shulis Legal fund visit FIGHTHEDABBLER.COM

Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

follow our “Results girl” Danni on Instagram @Danni_Desolation

follow the “Keeper of Consequences” Mahalia @mahellllyeah

This week on The Creep Off, we’re headed to south America to make our nominations for the biggest creep in Venezuela! 

Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff

Check out this week’s scum parade stories here: 

Rogue surgeon at Great Ormond Street Hospital ‘hurt up to 100 children’ through botched surgeries on their legs

Wisconsin Man Hurled Baby at Wall Because He Was Losing Video Game | Us Weekly

Woman badly disfigured and facing millions of dollars in medical bills after stranger hurled acid on her as she enjoyed night out | Daily Mail Online

Maniac NYC driver who mowed down teen girl who rejected him, had suspended license: docs | New York Post

The score is currently Vinnie 1 – Karl 3 – Guest 4 visit thecreepoff.com to vote and decide this week’s winner

Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon & Supercast to snag exclusive merch and get an extra bonus episode every week!

Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

You can follow our Results girl Danni on Instagram @Danni_Desolation 

Karl & Vinnie nominate the biggest creep of 2025 and dive into a Holiday Hangover Scum Parade. Most importantly we learn to never mock the power of a Sonichu medallion 

The score is currently Vinnie 1 – Karl 2 – Guest 4 visit patreon.com/thecreepoff to vote and decide this week’s winner

Check out this week’s scum parade stories here: 

Man accused of stealing mandolins in Teaneck returns them with apology note

Salvation Army bell ringer tries to impale Florida Publix manager with donation tripod, deputies say | WFLA

ICE Arrests NJ Santa Impersonator Following Child Porn Charges | Princeton, NJ Patch

Elderly Seattle woman has eye gouged out in random attack by repeat thug — as cops admit ‘he’s notorious’ | New York Post

Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to snag exclusive merch and get an extra bonus episode every week!

Support free speech help to donate to Karl & Shulis Legal fund visit FIGHTHEDABBLER.COM

Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

You can follow our Results girl Danni on Instagram @Danni_Desolation

Join us for our yearly Creepmas celebration! Pour some eggnog, send the kids to grandmas, and settle in for the most uncomfortable holiday tradition you didn’t ask for but definitely deserve!

. The score is currently Vinnie 1 – Karl 1 – Guest 4 visit patreon.com/thecreepoff to vote and decide this week’s winner1

https://www.crimeonline.com/2025/12/19/scheming-dad-had-lookalike-friend-take-court-ordered-paternity-test-to-avoid-paying-child-support/

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15401691/Moment-drunken-usher-arrested-biting-fellow-guests-finger-best-friends-wedding.html

https://lawandcrime.com/crime/her-leg-felt-cold-jealous-man-beat-girlfriend-in-the-face-with-ceramic-ashtray-before-using-pillow-to-kill-her-and-then-lay-next-to-corpse/

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15377469/NSW-Moorland-Bestiality-Beast-Boy-Colin-Baker.html

Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to snag exclusive merch and get an extra bonus episode every week!

Get yourself or someone you love the most fun game this side of cape coral! Dabble Dice! Grab yours here:

Support free speech help to donate to Karl & Shuli’s Legal fund visit FIGHTHEDABBLER.COM

Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

You can follow our Results girl Danni on Instagram @Danni_Desolation

 This week, Karl and Vinnie head to the Crossroads of America to make their nominations for the biggest creep in the Hoosier State: Indiana. The Scum Parade rolls through with a fresh lineup of absolute garbage humans, we meet a man who cannot handle taking orders from a female police officer, and Vinnie sets a record for speed on completing his latest consequence.