Watch our latest episode
Podcast Episodes
Episode 320: Old Habits Die Hard
After a month of Pride-themed creep categories, we’re throwing out the rules. One final wildcard matchup will decide who earns the dubious honor of being crowned the creepiest of them all. Karl and Vinnie will also bring you another edition of Karl’s Cop Cam, a fresh Scum Parade packed with the internet’s latest degenerates, and your voicemails.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Anthrocon marks 20 years of bringing furries to Pittsburgh
NY grandma likely poisoned, stabbed grandkids, daughter in murder-suicide: cops
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
The score is currently Vinnie 1` – Karl 2 – Guest 4
Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon, Supercast to snag exclusive merch and get an extra bonus episode every week!
Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108
You can follow our results girl Mahalia @mahellllyeah
You can follow our Results girl Danni on Instagram @Danni_Desolation
Episode 319: Who Da Man? Who Da Man?
#258 Who Da Man?
This week on The Creep Off, Karl & Vinnie continue their Pride Month celebration by tackling the biggest category of them all: Who Is the Creepiest “+”?
In this installment of Karl’s Cop Cam, we meet a non-binary indigenousness, anxiety and generational traumatized drunk driver! Oh Boy! Plus a brand-new scum parade, and most importantly Danni asks us to judge her bikini!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
The score is currently Vinnie 1` – Karl 1 – Guest 4
Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon, Supercast to snag exclusive merch and get an extra bonus episode every week!
Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108
You can follow our results girl Mahalia @mahellllyeah
You can follow our Results girl Danni on Instagram @Danni_Desolation
Episode 318: Hey! I Recognize that Blanket!
This week on The Creep Off, Karl & Vinnie continue their Pride Month celebration by asking one very important question Who Is the Creepiest “T”? Which “T” will pass and claim the title? We’re joined by Mahalia to go over our new consequences before Vinnie spins the Wheel! We’ll also watch a brand-new edition of Karl’s Cop Cam and learn how the Lord works in mysterious ways in this week’s Scum Parade.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
God told me to do it:’ Woman jailed for allegedly throwing 10-month-old daughter out window
Louisville man arrested, accused of sexual acts with dog | Crime Reports | wdrb.com
Funeral director decapitated 92-year-old woman’s body, threw head into ravine
N.H. man accused of using gun to threaten woman into marriage
The score is currently Vinnie 0 – Karl 1 – Guest 4
Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon, Supercast to snag exclusive merch and get an extra bonus episode every week!
Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108
You can follow our results girl Mahalia @mahellllyeah
You can follow our Results girl Danni on Instagram @Danni_Desolation
Episode 317: A Long Trip Down a Dirt Road
Pride Month rolls on, and this week Karl & Vinnie are celebrating by nominating the Creepiest “G”! Who will earn this prestigious and completely unwanted title? We’ll be digging through another collection of all-around pieces of garbage to determine which “G” is the worst of them all! In this installment of Karl’s Cop Cam, we meet a teacher/wine enthusiast who needed more booze! In the Scum Parade, we meet an office hero who took a stand, an amateur magician and a reminder to keep your pets on a leash
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
South Carolina Detective Charged After Pulling Gun on Officer Over Fish in Microwave
Woman ‘smuggled full bottle of Pinot Grigio into prison inside her vagina’ – Daily Star
Man hurled boy down ravine after his dogs killed him: AG
Woman Gets 18 Years After Throwing Dynamite at Sleeping Boyfriend, Blowing Off His Hand
The score is currently Vinnie 0 – Karl 0 – Guest 4
Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon, Supercast to snag exclusive merch and get an extra bonus episode every week!
Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108
You can follow our results girl Mahalia @mahellllyeah
You can follow our Results girl Danni on Instagram @Danni_Desolation
Episode 316: Leggo My Preggo
Pride Month is here, and Karl & Vinnie are celebrating the only way they know how—by asking one very important question: Who Is the Creepiest “L”? In this installment of Karl’s Cop Cam, we meet an expectant mother who terrorizes sex shops with her child in tow, and appears to have built quite an impressive collection of drugs and alcohol: In the Scum Parade, we learn why you should never cheap out on a casket, discover that cats don’t fly, and find out that sometimes it’s better to end a situation before it gets even worse.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
https://nypost.com/2026/05/28/world-news/body-falls-out-of-bottom-of-casket-at-funeral-as-mourners-scream/
https://nypost.com/2026/05/31/us-news/cops-bust-creep-carrying-pet-fish-and-exposing-his-chimichanga-outside-florida-taco-bell/
https://www.nydailynews.com/2026/05/26/bronx-man-killed-cat-threw-window-prosecutors/
https://www.courier-journal.com/story/News/local/public-safety/2026/05/27/lmpd-shooting-kills-man-suspected-of-homeless-killing/90264396007/
The score is currently Vinnie 3` – Karl 4 – Guest 4
Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon, Supercast to snag exclusive merch and get an extra bonus episode every week!
Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108
You can follow our results girl Mahalia @mahellllyeah
You can follow our Results girl Danni on Instagram @Danni_Desolation
Episode 315: That’s All We Had Karen!
Join Karl & Vinnie for the Annual Memorial Day Scum Parade, a holiday tradition unlike any other. We’re digging through some of the biggest degenerates, scumbags, predators, weirdos, and absolute disasters so you don’t have to! Plus, we check out Brittany Spears arrest video.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Police: Montgomery County man shows up drunk to pick up friend from DWI arrest – WNYT.com NewsChannel 13
Notorious ‘Pee Pee Poo Poo Man’ busted for 2 alleged sexual assaults
Man had sex with his wife who is also his daughter after she ‘competed with sister’ – AOL
Girl, 15, charged with plot to kill classmate blames internet for making her a ‘horrible person’
Transgender Serial Killer Convicted of Slaying, Dismembering Third Female Victim – Reduxx
Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon, Supercast to snag exclusive merch and get an extra bonus episode every week!
Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108
You can follow our results girl Mahalia @mahellllyeah
You can follow our Results girl Danni on Instagram @Danni_Desolation