This week Vinnie & Karl are joined in studio by former WWE Superstar Colin Delaney (@extremelycute on Twitter and @extremelycolin on Instagram) to make their nominations for the creepiest wrestler not named Chris Benoit: The boys give an update on the new patreon score: In the Scum Parade we meet an axe wielding slot machine junkie, we learn about the greatest live stream channel ever and finally we learn how to happy tap with Elmo!

Ladies & Gentlemen please enjoy this very special Hall of Fame Induction episode of the Creep Off. Today we learn all about the rise and fall of disgraced sandwich eater Jared Fogle!

Please take a second and join us on Patreon for future Hall of Fame Episodes other bonuses and cool merch! https://www.patreon.com/TheCreepOff

In spite of never completing a book in their lives Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest author: In the scum parade we meet the new Russian Olympic baby throwing champion, we learn to never mix Nyquil with other medications and why you should not go to home depot for cosmetic surgery supplies.

This week Vinnie & Karl welcome spring by submitting their nominations for Easters worst of the worst: In the scum parade we meet a Mom who is not afraid to get her fist dirty, a pervy Bank Teller and a nude guy named Carl.

This week Vinnie, PJ Philliam & Brian McBride are your guides through the biggest meltdown of season 25 of the Bachelor

In honor of St. Patrick this week Vinnie & Karl search for the creepiest descendent of the Emerald Isle: In the Scum Parade we make a stop in the greatest city in the world, we meet a fake cosmetic surgeon and a man who borrowed his grandfather’s ear: Finally the Wheel of Consequences is spun and Karl is not pleased